top of page

Buying a Rental Property in Nashville: What to Check Before You Make an Offer

Writer: Rachel Mays
Rachel Mays
Jul 20
3 min read

Updated: Oct 25

A rental property can be a strong long-term asset in Nashville. It can also be an expensive lesson if the numbers, the zoning or the condition don't hold up after closing. Most of the costly mistakes I see happen before the offer is ever written, so this is the checklist I work through with clients who are buying to rent.

For context, I'm a Tennessee-licensed real estate broker with eXp Realty and a former city planner, and I've represented buyers and sellers here since 2016. Nothing below is legal or tax advice. For that, bring in an attorney and a CPA who work with real estate investors.

Start with the strategy, not the listing

A long-term rental, a furnished mid-term rental for traveling nurses and relocating professionals, and a short-term rental are three different businesses with different rules, tenants and risks. Decide which one you're buying for, and whether the property still works if you have to switch. A home that only makes sense as a short-term rental is a riskier purchase than one that also works as a long-term rental.

Confirm zoning and permit status before you rely on any income

In Nashville, what you can legally do with a property depends heavily on its zoning and, for short-term rentals, on permit status and owner occupancy. One example: Metro no longer issues new non-owner-occupied short-term rental permits for properties in RM (multifamily) zoning. Where an existing permit sits inside an LLC, a buyer may be purchasing the LLC itself through a Member Interest Purchase Agreement rather than buying the property directly, which changes the contract, the due diligence and how the property can be marketed. Don't assume you can buy in your own name and move the property into an LLC later to keep a permit. Get the zoning and permit status confirmed before any projected rent goes into your math.

Run your own numbers, conservatively

Listing projections and online rent estimates are a starting point, not underwriting. Build your own monthly picture: realistic rent for that unit on that street, property taxes, insurance, HOA dues, any utilities you'll cover, routine maintenance, reserves for big-ticket items like the roof and HVAC, vacancy, and management if you won't manage it yourself. For furnished rentals, add furnishings, supplies, cleaning and platform fees. Then stress-test it. What happens if rent comes in lower than you hoped, or the unit sits empty for a couple of months? If the deal only works in the best case, it doesn't work.

Inspect like you'll own it for ten years

Investors sometimes waive inspection items to win a deal, and that's usually where the profit goes. Pay close attention to roof age, HVAC, drainage and foundation, sewer lines on older homes, electrical panels, and anything a tenant or guest would call you about at midnight. Nashville's older housing stock can be charming and solid, or it can hide decades of deferred maintenance.

Look at the street, not just the zip code

Rental demand can change block by block. Proximity to employers, hospitals, universities, transit corridors and entertainment districts affects who will rent from you and what they'll pay. Because of my planning background, I also look at what's likely to change nearby, including rezoning activity, planned development and infrastructure projects that can help or hurt a property over time.

Line up financing that fits the property

Loans for investment property work differently from owner-occupied loans, often with larger down payments and different pricing. Some purchases, such as buying an LLC through a Member Interest Purchase Agreement, may call for a different financing approach entirely. Talk with a lender who regularly works with investors before you start shopping, so your offer is credible when you find the right property.

Know your exit before you enter

Decide how you'd eventually get out: sell, refinance, or switch to a different rental model. Ask who the next buyer would be and whether zoning, permit status or condition would shrink that pool. The best purchases leave you with more than one good option.

Get a second set of eyes

If you're looking at a Nashville rental property, I'm glad to walk through the zoning, the condition and the numbers with you before you commit. Get in touch here or call or text 615-855-9313.

Comments


bottom of page